Why Neocate Dropped the Soy Oil

Posted 1.17.16 | Nutrition Specialist

Loads of parents and caregivers, and even some healthcare professionals, contact us asking about the various ingredients in our Neocate products. Here are some common questions we receive:

  • Why do you include ___ as an ingredient? (It provides nutrition is almost always the answer.)
  • Does Neocate use GMOs? (Nope!)
  • Do Neocate products contain soy? (No way!)   

That last question is one of my favorites, because our answer is so unique. Many of you may be aware that a lot of infants with a cow milk allergy also are allergic to soy. This is sometimes termed milk soy protein intolerance (MSPI). For many, many years Neocate families have asked us over and over if we could remove the soy oil from Neocate Infant. They told us that, while the medical community told them soy oil was okay, they were still wary. On top of requests from parents, some healthcare professionals also asked us if it would be possible to remove soy oil (more on that below). I'll tell you the history behind removing soy oil from Neocate Infant, and I'll also try to answer some questions from a medical perspective about soy oil for those with a soy allergy.

Why did Neocate use soy oil in the past?

For about 20 years, Neocate Infant products in the United States contained soy oil. The oil was very highly refined, and the refining process is designed to remove all of the protein, which is the part of food that the body responds to in an allergic reaction. The soy oil was essential because it provides special types of fats that human infants need to get from their diet. If a baby can't breast feed and drinks formula instead, the formula is required by law to contain these essential fats.  For many years, soy oil was really the only good source of essential fat that was also permitted for infant formulas. In fact, every infant formula in the United States uses soy oil to provide essential fats.

What changed?

I mentioned that Neocate Infant used soy oil, but other Neocate products for older children did not. That's because those products contain canola oil as a source of essential fat instead of soy oil. Canola oil is an excellent source of essential fat, and can be used in foods for children and older people in the US, but had not been able to be used for infant formulas. You know what's really weird? Neocate Infant products in other countries used canola oil instead of soy oil for years! 

At Nutricia, we thought it would be great if canola oil were suitable for use in Neocate Infant too, but there has to be a lot of evidence for the ingredients that can be used in infant formulas, and the evidence has to be given to the Federal Drug Administration (FDA). Basically, nobody had ever told the FDA that they would like to use canola oil in an infant formula as a source of essential fat. We decided that we wanted to do what we could to replace the soy oil with canola oil in Neocate Infant, because it was important to our customers. This involved working with experts and compiling loads of research and information to provide the FDA to support the safety of canola oil.

Ultimately, we were able to provide the FDA with the available research and with answers to all of their questions. Based on the long history of safe use in other countries and the fact that canola oil is a great source of essential fats, we were able to remove the soy oil in Neocate Infant DHA/ARA! In 2013, we finally launched an improved version of Neocate Infant DHA/ARA. Among other nutritional improvements, soy oil was not in the formula. The formula contained canola oil instead, and had higher levels of essential fats.

What does the medical community say?

As I mentioned above, soy oil is recognized by the medical community as being suitable for patients with soy allergies. The soy oil used in infant formulas is highly refined, whereas some grocery oils labeled "cold pressed" or "unfiltered" are not. Professional allergy organizations have published guidance for allergic patients indicating that refined soy oil is acceptable for most patients. In fact, the FDA exempts highly refined soy oil from being labeled as an allergen, due to the available research indicating safety.

Despite this, many healthcare professionals told us that it is confusing for families who find it easy to avoid products with "soy" on the label. They informed us that many families are inherently suspicious of infant formulas that contain soy oil if their infant has a soy allergy. It can be very difficult for healthcare teams to reassure parents that the soy oil used in infant formulas is "safe" for an infant with a soy protein allergy, especially if the family has been through many allergy symptoms and unsuccessful formula switches. Families want the greatest assurance possible that a formula is "safe." 

Many healthcare professionals have thanked us for removing soy oil from Neocate Infant. They know that the soy oil was safe, but felt it would be much easier to provide a parent with an infant formula that didn't contain any ingredients derived from soy, regardless of the inherent safety of the ingredient. The fact that the improved Neocate Infant formula contained higher levels of essential fats was an added nutritional bonus. To this day, Neocate Infant is the only infant formula available in the U.S. that does not contain soy oil. We feel it was worth the time and effort to remove soy oil from Neocate Infant, and we're glad to say that there is no soy oil in the entire Neocate product line.

Do you find it reassuring that Neocate products do not contain soy oil?


Image source

Read my bio here.

Add Comment

Leave a Comment  Read our Comments & Trackbacks Policy before submitting a comment.

Required fields *

About Us

Food Allergy Living is a resource for parents of children with food allergies, brought to you by Nutricia, the makers of Neocate. For more in-depth information about our purpose & authors, see our About Food Allergy Living page.